Disclaimer: Everyone is entitled to his or her opinion, myself included. This post is written through my eyes, as a “skinny” girl… having always been… the “skinny” girl. This post is in no way meant to be offensive; however, I am aware that it may be taken as so. I hope (that as adults)… that regardless of your agreement or disagreement with my post, you can & will respect my feelings. Thank you.
__________
Lets talk Tri-State, since it is one of my main reasons for writing a post that is going to put my emotions, dignity, & integrity on the line…
(I’m going to cut right to the chase & start with Event 1)
Event 1 – 8 minute AMRAP of 9 (20″) Box Jumps, 6 Hand Release Push-Ups, 3 Front Squats (65#). Strategically, I decided to pace myself during Event 1. At this time, I was unaware of just how many events I would partake in throughout the day & what those events would consist of, so I didn’t want to burn myself out at the beginning. My goal was to complete 5 rounds, so when I completed 7 +11, I was pretty happy with myself. Then I started to hear some of the other girls’ rounds… 8+, 9+, even 10+. I went from feeling pretty good about my 7+ rounds to feeling not so good about my 7+ rounds. To make myself feel better, I reminded myself why I didn’t go all out on Event 1, which seemed to help a little bit. I was ready & felt good going into…
Event 2 – ‘Grace’ (30 Clean & Jerks for time) at 65#. I have to admit… ‘Grace’ had me pretty nervous. I remembered it being death when I had done it just a month prior… or so I thought it was death, but when 3, 2, 1, GO happened… and I picked up the bar, I didn’t remember it feeling as light in January, as it did in this moment, but I was using the same weight I had used a month ago (65#). I banged the first 10 C&J’s out at a pretty good pace, the second 10 out a little slower, & the third 10 I broke into 5 + 5. *Shout out to Amit for being a super judge & getting me to pick the bar up when all I really wanted was a few more seconds of rest!* My goal for ‘Grace’ wasn’t specific, but rather… just beat your time you had a month ago… and I did! On January 7th, I finished ‘Grace’ in 4:34 at 65#. At Tri-State (February 11th), I finished ‘Grace’ in 3:50 at 65#! That’s a 44 seconds improvement in only ONE month… FOURTY FOUR SECONDS IMPROVEMENT!!!!! I was STOKED! Not only did I beat my ‘Grace’ time from a month before, but I beat it pretty significantly (at least in my eyes). So here I am feeling awesome about my new ‘Grace’ time when I start to hear the ‘Grace’ time of some of the other girls… 1:45, 2:08, etc. Back came that feeling that my good, was not so good after all. ‘Grace’ took almost everything out of me & I was feeling pretty wiped/verging on crappy, going into…
Event 3 – 6 minutes to establish 1 rep max Continental Clean & Jerk… rest 4 minutes… 6 minutes to Row as many meters as possible. The Continental Clean & Jerk was frustrating for a couple reasons… 1 – having to load & unload the bar took time & energy away from what I had to give to the movement itself, 2 – the clips were new & I had difficulty getting them on/off, 3 – the weights I had were all messed up (ex: I had an odd number of 10′s & no 15′s), which made calculating even more difficult than usual. I CC&J’d 80#, which I was happy with (failed at 85#). I was exhausted going into the row, even with 4 minutes rest in between. I told my judge (who I didn’t know) to yell at me, like really yell at me… because that always seems to help me. Whatever the reason, I had NOTHING left in me. Literally… NOTHING. You ever see those idiots (sorry if you’re one of them, haha) try to climb up the down escalators?? …Yea, that’s how I felt. I was getting nowhere. And my judge yelled… believe me, she yelled – “PUSH WITH YOUR LEGS! BIGGER PULLS! GET IT UNDER 2:10!” It didn’t matter how much she yelled or what she yelled, I had nothing in me & was going nowhere & my split time crept higher & higher. I think this may have been the worst 6 minutes in my CrossFit life…
Event 4 – 3 rounds for time of 7 Deadlifts (135#), 14 Air Squats, & 21 Single Unders. I feel indifferent about this Event… most likely because it was the last event & I was exhausted & looking forward to being done at this point. I don’t really have much to say about Event 4… I could have done it a little bit faster, but it was fine… (or maybe I have nothing to say about this event because my brain was hurting/not functioning by this point in the day, haha).
__________
A “Skinny” Girl’s Perspective…
Long day complete, I felt pretty good about my performances, with the exception of my row, which was awful… so when results were posted on ACF’s main page… I scrolled down until I came across my name… and there it was… next to the number 43. At this point, different waves of emotions swept through me… the most prominent… upset & disappointment, with anger & frustration following.
I was upset & disappointed because I thought I would have placed better than 43rd. (This is where I should mention that I placed 43 out of 49… understand why I felt upset/disappointed now?) I was angered & frustrated because this brought up a factor that bothers me in CrossFit, especially when it comes to competitions… a factor that usually plays against me… and that factor is my petite size. I am in no way complaining about being petite. I am very happy with my body right now & am moving in a healthy, forward direction regarding my food intake & my training. I am merely stating that size isn’t taken into consideration when it comes to CrossFit. I am about 5’1 & 1/2… and average 113lbs.
Lets take Event 1, which consisted of Front Squats 65#… that’s MORE THAN HALF my body weight. To make math easy, lets say a female competitor of mine weighs 200lbs. 65# is 30lbs. LESS THAN HALF her body weight… so she’s front squatting much less than half her body weight, while I am front squatting more than half my body weight. Fair? I’d say not.
Lets take Event 2, which consisted of Clean & Jerks 65#. Again, I am C&J’ing MORE THAN HALF my body weight, while a woman weighing 200lbs. is C&J’ing 30lbs. LESS THAN HALF of her body weight. Fair? I’d say not.
Event 3 – While 80# Continental Clean & Jerk is pretty awesome for me, “bigger” people can push more weight… I won’t say 100% of the time, but I’d say it’s pretty given…
And then there was Event 4, with Deadlifts at 135#… I had to deadlift about 20lbs. MORE than my body weight, while a woman weighing 200lbs. lifted significantly LESS than her body weight. Fair? I’d say not.
You might say, “Well Carissa, life’s not fair.” And you’re right… life isn’t fair, buuttt… when it comes to a competition that is said to determine “fit” …I would be deemed fairly un-fit given my placement among those in the rec division. Yes, there will always be somebody who is more “fit” than me… and I will always have room to improve my state of “fit,” but I think it is safe for me to say that I am a fairly fit person. Can my strength still increase – yes! Are there CrossFit movements I don’t have yet that I will one day have – absolutely! But that doesn’t mean that I’m not fit now.
CrossFit competitions don’t take into consideration that while I was front squatting & clean & jerking more than half my body weight, other women were doing the same at much less than half their body weight. CrossFit competitions don’t take into consideration that while I was deadlifting more than my body weight, other women were deadlifting much less than their body weight… and yet, we are supposed to be ranked “fit” under the same standards. CrossFit does not recognize the amount of weight that I can push/pull/lift in relation to my size/weight. This is where my problem lies.
While I am upset & frustrated with everything I have just written about above, at the end of the day… I have to & need to know that I front squatted & clean & jerked more than half my body weight & that I deadlifted more than my body weight… and that most importantly, I improved my ‘Grace’ time by 44 seconds in one month.
I guess what I’m trying to get at is that I don’t think CrossFit competitions are a true & accurate measure of fitness. If competitions were based on pushing/pressing/lifting a certain percentage of a person’s body weight, than yes… that would be a more accurate way to determine “fit.” A quick, google definition of fit is “in good physical condition; in good health.” …of which I consider myself both.
So which am I?? I think it’s safe to say that I am fit. The Tri-State Competition would say, not so much…
Yours Truly,
- C